decolonization / estoria

An Anti-Anti-American Response

For two days last week, Victoria Leon Guerrero and I, as co-chairs of the Independence for Guam Task Force worked as guest hosts for K57. As “Independent Guahan on the Radio” we spoke with guest attorney Mike Phillips, we took more than three dozens calls, and explained why we both support independence as Guam’s next political status, and why others should consider it as well. Overall the six hours we spent on the air were fantastic, a few callers called in, challenging us in a variety of ways, but we countered back in polite ways, hoping to get people to think beyond the narrow ways that people were proposing we consider our possibilities as an island or a people. One thing which always emerges around these types of conversations, is the notion that to speak about decolonization or independence is supremely and cravenly “anti-American.

Recent months have been brimming with discussions on decolonization, self-determination and political status change for Guam, and the Independence for Guam Task Force has been working to take advantage of this particularly fertile time for these types of conversations. We’ve had teach-in, forums, and outreach. I even started a temporary website recently, where we can keep materials and post flyers and other updates.

Governor Calvo spent a large part of his State of the Island Address earlier this year talking about Guam’s political status and laid out a bold plan to hold a political status vote by the end of the year. Calvo’s proposal created a stir in the community, especially among those who have been fighting for self-determination for decades, as it seemed to open the right to vote in a self-determination plebiscite to all registered voters and not just those who are considered to be “native inhabitants.”

Calvo presented his plans to the Commission on Decolonization, of which I am a member, representing the Independence for Guam Task Force, soon after his speech. We had some very spirited discussion on the Governor’s plans, sharing our concerns, but also expressing our appreciation for his new aggressive pushing of the issue. Thankfully the Governor agreed to forgo using the referendum process to hold a plebiscite, and instead work with the Commission on Decolonization, to focus on public education and resolving legal impediments that currently complicate this process. As someone who has committed much of my life to seeing Guam decolonized, this is incredibly exciting.

This was months ago, and unfortunately little has happened in terms of movement from the Governor’s office since then. They had a radical and aggressive plan to increase education over a two month period, but accomplished so little of it. It is unfortunate that the current and previous Governor of Guam don’t seem to hold a great deal of visible or proactive passion about this topic. The current Governor doesn’t seem to understand how much work preparing the Guam community, both those who are Chamorro and those who are not, for a vote on political status. Centuries of colonization and Chamorros swimming and breathing in a debilitating colonial fog cannot be cleared out of our systems in just a few months, regardless of how well intended such expedited plans might be. One of the reasons why education is so necessary, is because of that perception that this issue is “anti-American.”

Guam has been a colony for centuries. Its treatment as a colony has changed depending on who is doing the colonizing and what their interests are. Spanish colonization had several different phases and faces, as does American colonialism. This first and sometimes most difficult step in conducting a public education campaign about decolonization is getting people to recognize the need for political status change. Getting them to see that there is something wrong with the current political order and that things could be better if it was changed. If Guam was currently being colonized by a small and unassuming country, it would be easier to convince people of the need to change things. But when your colonizer is the self-proclaimed greatest country in the world, some of that bravado trickles down, and people in the colonies will come to accept it as truth. Under those ideological conditions people come to see all possibility for the future not only through their colonizer, but tied to their colonizer. It is primarily for this reason that discussions about decolonization have always been inhibited due to fears of such ideas being anti-American.

When the first modern conversations about political status change began, few were sure about how to talk about it. The idea of Guam being anything other than a colonial possession was daunting and it felt ungrateful and wrong to reject the existing way in which Guam is tied to the United States. Generations of self-determination activists endured the slings and arrows of being labeled “anti-American” because of their beliefs that Guam should be decolonized and that Chamorros should be given the chance to determine their political destiny after centuries of colonization. But I am grateful for their efforts, as it has brought us to the point today, where fewer and fewer people understand political status in such narrow and inaccurate terms.

After all, if you pay attention to the voices of the some men who are credited with founding the United States, they would seem to be very support of Guam’s colonization, as they were struggling against their own forms of disenfranchisement, discrimination and colonial restriction. The rhetoric that gave birth to the United States has been something that has been the model for so many other movements for decolonization and independence in the centuries since. This is true, despite the fact that the United States has scarcely lived up to its own lofty rhetoric, as it was created atop the disenfranchisement of women, the massive displacement of Native Americans and the continued enslavement of African Americans. Regardless of how you see the “spirit” of the United States today, during its genesis, there was a clear anti-colonial spirit and loud condemnations of colonization and also the rights of those who are colonized to become free and independent.

The thoughts of Thomas Jefferson are a good place to start when looking for this type of relevant rhetoric. I’ll list three quotes here from Jefferson, you may have heard them in the context of US history, but imagine them instead in the context of Guam’s decolonization:

“Every man, and every body of men on earth, possesses the right of self-government.”

“Every nation has a right to govern itself internally under what forms it pleases, and to change these forms at its own will.”

“May it be to the world, what I believe it will be … the signal of arousing men to burst the chains … and to assume the blessings and security of self-government.”

Or if perhaps Jefferson isn’t close enough to the core of what makes America America, take for instance this passage from the Declaration of Independence:

“But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.–Such has been the patient sufferance of these Colonies; and such is now the necessity which constrains them to alter their former Systems of Government.”

You could easily take this document upon which people claim the spirit of a great country was born, and rework it to reflect the historical experiences of Chamorros. What does it mean then when a country so obsessed with expounding and solid-gold-engraving the world with its greatness has trouble remembering its own decolonial origins? Or that the United States has trouble accepting the fact that the colonial injustices that helped spark its own birth may still exist and that the US itself may very well be the perpetrator?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s